Forum on open reviews and course experience

We ask you to consider two issues in this forum:

1. Open review platform. What is your view of the use of open review platforms, you might refer to the paper Preprint review services: Disrupting the scholarly communication landscape which we presented above.

2. Reflecting on assignment answers. What do you think are the reasons for the differences between the majority of the participant responses and those given by the tutors in the model answers? In particular that only 13% of the participants suggested Approve with major revisions - which was the preferred response in the model answer.